« July 2009 | Main | September 2009 »
August 14, 2009
Learning from the Town Halls
As you may have heard, Obama is literally Hitler.
To be clear, this comparison is odious and offensive and awful in ways too numerous to count, but it's also useful--precisely because it's odious and offensive and awful.
That kind of vitriol can be a good reminder of how quickly heated rhetoric can turn into poisonous rhetoric. For those of us who work in politics, especially those of us who work in the language of politics, it's prudent to stop every once in a while to make sure that you're still on the same planet as everyone else and that you're making claims that are fundamentally humane.
If you're comparing Obama to Hitler, you're not. If you're comparing Bush to Hitler, you're not. If you're screaming about death panels you're not. If you're saying that McCain is nuts you're . . . probably not? If you're saying Sarah Palin is a fool you . . . are? Aren't? Want to be?
It's a tricky line to walk, especially when the stakes are high and feelings are strong. There but for a habit of self awareness go we.
Posted by Drew at 03:44 PM
August 12, 2009
Revisiting Books
In seventh grade we were assigned to choose a mystery novel, then present a report on it to the class. Since I was, even then, a snob, I chose Smilla's Sense of Snow, which Time Magazine had called the Best Book of 1993.
Unfortunately, I only made it through 150 pages before giving up and reading an Agatha Christie novel, which was probably more suited to my reading level (and which had a much more likable protagonist.)
A few weeks ago, I picked up another copy of my original choice and decided to give it another go. This led to the interesting sensation of total familiarity with all the exposition I had read 15 years ago, but very little of the action. So when I read about Smilla's childhood in Greenland, it fit comfortably with all my old impressions of her life; but when she set sail on a mysterious voyage to the north Atlantic, I suddenly found myself having to make a similar transition alongside her: away from the familiar and towards the unknown. Her perspective was almost totally aligned with mine, and the adventure she undertakes contrasts with her daily life as sharply for me as it does for her.
I'm not sure how exactly one could replicate this experience short of reading the first hundred pages of a mystery, then setting it aside for a decade or so. Perhaps it's akin to reading about Harry Potter's time at Hogwarts over a seven year period and facing the same intoxicating sense of urgency that Harry feels to see how the whole thing will turn out. In either case, it's quite a pleasant feeling, and I recommend it heartily if you can find a way to make it work.
Posted by Drew at 04:04 PM
August 10, 2009
Why has Randall Munroe been following me around?
Posted by Drew at 05:21 PM